spendmatters
 

May 16, 2012

 

Ariba Sells Sourcing Services, BPO Businesses to Accenture

In a surprise move, Ariba announced this morning that they were selling their sourcing services and BPO businesses to Accenture. At the time of the announcement, it was not clear whether all of these assets would end up with Accenture's BPO group or their consultancy organization (within Accenture, unlike other large hybrid consulting/BPO organizations, the lines between the divisions are somewhat blurry). According to the announcement, "upon the closing of the acquisition, Accenture will take ownership of these assets, which include Ariba's category expertise, sourcing process expertise and strategic sourcing execution resources, strengthening Accenture's position as a leading provider of sourcing and procurement consulting and outsourcing services."

The company press release suggests "approximately 160 Ariba employees are expected to join Accenture upon the closing of the transaction." The deal is not yet closed, but Ariba forecasts closing by the end of the December quarter. Accenture is buying these assets for $39 million up-front, with an additional "$12 million of which is subject to escrow to be released based on the assignment and performance of certain assets." The earn-out that is part of this agreement will no-doubt incent Ariba to refer services business to Accenture, potentially at the expense of other services partners.

In a letter to Ariba employees this morning, Bob Calderoni told his staff that "As you all know, Ariba has its sights set on a lofty goal: to become the leading platform for business-to-business commerce. And in order to do this, we must focus on developing and delivering on-demand solutions that enable companies to buy, sell and manage their cash more efficiently and effectively. In support of this vision and mission, we have made a strategic decision to sell our sourcing services and business process outsourcing (BPO) business to Accenture, one of the world's largest and most successful management consulting, technology services and outsourcing companies."

Bob continues: "Under the terms of a definitive agreement announced this morning, Accenture will take ownership of Ariba's sourcing services business ... Our customers will continue to receive the services they have contracted for and will benefit from Accenture's deep expertise and extended global reach. In addition, Ariba will provide access to Accenture's services through the Ariba Commerce Cloud, enabling companies seeking additional resources and expertise to support their strategic sourcing efforts to tap them as needed."

Bob suggests that strategically, "Divesting this portion of our business and expanding our partner ecosystem to include world-class companies like Accenture will allow us to focus on what we at Ariba do best: developing and delivering network-based solutions that enable companies to lower costs, minimize risk and optimize performance and cash flow. It will also help in the execution of our strategy, by providing additional cash to support and accelerate the growth of our business."

In a note to financial analysts this morning, Ariba also suggested that "We will retain Services tied to our technology and adoption. Specifically, on demand set-up, adoption/value enablement services and upgrade implementation work in relation to our old CD offering."

In a column earlier this year, Spend Matters suggested that Ariba should divest or split apart its businesses into three groups, including its services and consulting arm. In this op-ed, I wrote that "the second P&L and ultimately, company, I would create would be focused entirely on services and content. Given how Ariba has not fully taken advantage of much of the original FreeMarkets services customer base which it could have parlayed into new revenue streams at a time when many competitors have seen double-digit services growth year over year, it's clear that opportunity still knocks in this space and the challenge for Ariba when it comes to maintaining -- let alone building -- a services P&L has been one of execution. With the assets of the Ariba GSO (formerly FreeMarkets) delivery organization combined with other productized services lines and more custom oriented work -- and the freedom to deliver objective advice on systems and process architecture separate from Ariba software -- I believe this group could rapidly become more competitive."'

Stay tuned for further analysis of the story throughout the day. Our initial take is that this transaction can be positive for both Ariba and Accenture. We'll leave the valuation and accretion/dilution analysis to the sell-side guys to give us their take on later today, but from a customer perspective, it looks like this deal could be a win / win based on the successful outcomes of the post acquisition / merger integration work by Accenture and Ariba's internal ability to refocus on what it does best -- not to mention starting to rebuild a previously broken partner ecosystem.

- Jason Busch


TweetBacks
Comments
David's Gravatar "in relation to our old CD offering" is a very telling statement. Ariba's focus is on the SaaS product and it is just a matter of time before the CD version is shut down and no longer supported.

I personally like that Ariba is focusing on the technology as the services branch provided no value to me as a customer. Focus is good.
# Posted By David | 10/6/10 12:04 PM
Jason Busch's Gravatar Agreed focus is key! I'm not sure, however, if Ariba can afford to divest itself of the CD business anytime soon ... the limitations of P2P integration and configuration, while better than before, would make it challenging for more complicated CD installs to migrate to SaaS.
# Posted By Jason Busch | 10/6/10 12:26 PM
Paul's Gravatar Focus on what? Being another supply chain software vendor? It seems to me Ariba is broadening it's technology footprint and pursuing interests other than Sourcing/Procurement - at the expense of business process focus.

I strongly disagree that this move helps them focus and would argue they are taking on the ERP providers for enterprise 'commerce' - a sad day for sourcing/procurement.
# Posted By Paul | 10/6/10 1:38 PM
Wally's Gravatar To further Paul's point, it appears they 'sold' Freemarkets (formerly $300m in annual revenue) for ~$50M when they paid almost 10x ($493M) only 6 years ago.

I guess they were unable to 'focus' on procurement/sourcing. As a former FMKT guy, it's a reminder that Ariba is a software developer and not a sourcing/procurement company.
# Posted By Wally | 10/6/10 1:46 PM
Jason Busch's Gravatar Paul / Wally,

Stay tuned for our take on this ... Ariba totally flubbed the FMKT asset. But better to get rid of it (Kevin Costello and team were not sourcing people and did not know how to create leverage from it) and put it in Accenture's hands than let it wilt on the vine even more.
# Posted By Jason Busch | 10/6/10 2:19 PM
Paul's Gravatar I agree, Jason, but what does that say about a software provider that builds sourcing software and, as you put it, are 'not sourcing people' ??? What is the pulse of Ariba's clients? This focus on software delivery is nice for your P/E ratio and shareholders but what about Ariba clients?
# Posted By Paul | 10/6/10 2:31 PM
China guys's Gravatar Ariba is not serious at all at sourcing, BPO services that they inherited from Freemarkets so selling them to Accenture is good to GSO guys.
# Posted By China guys | 10/6/10 9:27 PM
Hmmm...'s Gravatar If Ariba wants to focus on being a software vendor, maybe they should hire some execs who grew up in software world. Bob the bean counter is a far-cry from Marc Benioff. Kevin Costello is no Ray Lane. Seriously - look at the Ariba leadership team web page. Who on it other than Bhaskar has any enterprise software experience? Wasn't that FreeMarkets downfall? Trying to be a software company without any software executive leadership. I would not place my bets on focusing there with a team that doesn't understand the business of software. Good luck with that strategy.
# Posted By Hmmm... | 10/6/10 10:41 PM
Say that again's Gravatar Wally - are you saying that Ariba bought a company that had $300 million in revenues per year? Ariba's revenue today is only a little bit more than that? What happened?
# Posted By Say that again | 10/6/10 10:46 PM
About Us | Advertising and Sponsorships | Advisory Services | Contact Us    © 2004-2012 Azul Partners, Inc. and Spend Matters. All Rights Reserved.