spend matters spend matters About this site
Advertise with Spend Matters
Advertise with Spend Matters
 

March 11, 2010

 

In the Downturn, Are Dual Sourcing Strategies Best?

I recently came across a column that suggests dual sourcing is critical to protect supply chain integrity. According to the author, Robert M. Schooks, who serves as director of the Center for Manufacturing Improvement at Saginaw Valley State University, lower prices from global sources may not outweigh the "high disruption costs, should they surface," from overseas suppliers. Schooks suggests that, "the skill of balancing your needs should show a combination of domestic and international suppliers. If you order first from your local faster supplier and then tune in the overseas supplier to maintain your needs, you will achieve safety and cost reliability that could protect you should something negative occur anywhere in your supply chain."

Another suggestion -- that suppliers in today's challenging times where finding new business is more difficult than keeping existing customers, might be willing to take on -- is to have global suppliers take ownership and greater responsibility for warehousing and inventory management locally. Alternatively, today's economic climate might also be cause to negotiate more favorable payment terms with current overseas suppliers that might allow for the greater warehousing of local inventory to create buffer stock without increasing working capital requirements. Sure, you might get some push back initially. But I guarantee that many global suppliers are most concerned about losing business, and if they realize that you've got good local alternatives, they'll play ball when it comes to payment terms. That is, if they can still maintain sufficient cash flow to fund their operations.

Jason Busch

Comments
Talking about downturns, I have been following your blog for a while now. Back in the fall of 2007, you had downplayed the downsizing at Emptoris.

Apparently now it is really bad there. After all they have had two CFO changes in as many years (First Bill Geraughty took over in 2007 and now John Belchers takes over in just one year after Emptoris was supposedly planning on going public ?. Two CTOs in as many years - first it was Gary Li and then Burt Rubenstein and now both of them are gone ?

Not to mention two VPs of marketing, again in as many years and now on to the 3rd although Kevin Potts is home grown.

So what is really happening there ? Is it time to bail out of Emptoris Sourcing and Spend Management packages ? What is my product roadmap here and how am I going to be supported in the long run ?
# Posted By AK | 12/3/08 11:49 PM
This comment reeks of FUD. An Emptoris competitor, in fact, suggested that I delete it. But rather than censor it, it's worth saying that many other vendors that are more than 5 years old go through significant management shake-ups. Sometimes many times. This is a high turnover business. It's common. Also, regardless of whether Emptoris stays independent without raising more capital, raises more capital and stays independent or sells to another provider, the products will be supported.

Questions you should be asking:

1) Do the products work for you today?
2) Are you happy with the innovation roadmap?
3) Is the pricing (including maintenance and support) reasonable?
4) Are you getting the level of service required?
5) Is Emptoris communicating changes to you effectively?

CFOs and VPs of marketing aren't the ones who build products or service accounts. Don't worry about them if you are indeed a user (judging by the tone and knowledge of the comment, I wonder if you are a former employee with an axe to grind). What matters are the products, whether they are meeting your expectations, the service levels Emptoris is delivering and your comfort level with their direction (or at least your comfort with the fact that the products will be supported going forward by someone -- which I believe they will without question).
# Posted By Jason Busch | 12/4/08 8:28 AM
It may not indicate downsizing, but executive turnover seems to be a problem at Emptoris. In addition to the CFOs and CTOs that AK calls out, last year Emptoris lost Joe Jouhal, SVP Worldwide Sales, Eric Allen, VP/GM EMEA, and Mike Watson, VP of Customer Solutions. That a lot even in a high turnover business.
# Posted By JBoy | 12/12/08 5:59 AM
About Us | Advertising and Sponsorships | Advisory Services | Contact Us   © 2004-2010 Spend Matters, LP All rights reserved